Hiding Behind a Dating Checklist: How Insecurities Can Shape Our Dating Lives

As a matchmaker and relationship coach with close to a decade in the industry, I often encounter individuals who create detailed checklists to define their ideal partners. While this approach might seem practical, relying on a rigid set of criteria can highlight deeper insecurities and hinder the formation of genuine connections.

Consider Sarah, a client who has a meticulously crafted checklist for her ideal partner. It includes traits such as a specific height (6 feet or taller), a successful job in finance, and an Ivy League education. On the surface, this seems reasonable, but when I delve deeper, it becomes clear that Sarah is using her checklist as a shield. Each time she meets someone who doesn’t tick every box, she dismisses them outright, missing out on potentially great connections.

In fact, research shows that 62% of people create lists of attributes they want in a partner. However, let’s look at the numbers: only about 14% of men in the U.S. are over 6 feet tall, and only around 1.5% of men have a degree from an Ivy League school. Additionally, only about 20% of households earn $100,000 or more annually. This means that by setting these criteria, Sarah is narrowing her dating pool significantly and possibly missing out on great connections.

Dating can feel risky, especially after a long-term relationship. Take John, for example. When he returned to the dating scene, he felt overwhelmed and anxious. To cope, he created a checklist: his partner had to be within a specific age range, share his passion for sci-fi movies, and have a salary over $100,000. This rigid framework gave him a sense of control in an unpredictable dating world. However, when he met Lisa—who didn’t meet the income requirement but shared his adventurous spirit—he hesitated. John realized he was prioritizing financial stability over the genuine connection they could have formed.

The checklist often reveals underlying insecurities. For instance, Emily, who felt insecure about her own career, fixated on her partner’s job title and income. She believed that dating someone in a prestigious position would elevate her self-worth. This mindset led her to overlook Dave, a kind and supportive teacher who didn’t fit her "ideal" image but could have provided the emotional support she truly needed.

Statistics indicate that 72% of people admit to feeling pressure to date someone who meets societal expectations, which often manifests as a checklist mentality. This pressure can deepen insecurities, reinforcing the belief that our value is tied to external attributes.

To foster healthier dating experiences, I encourage my clients to reassess their checklist mentality. Here are some strategies I share:

Embrace Vulnerability: Open up about your feelings and insecurities. When Mark started discussing his fears of rejection with potential partners, he discovered that this vulnerability led to more authentic connections.

Focus on Relationship Core Values: Instead of adhering to a rigid checklist, consider what truly matters in a relationship. Jessica realized that qualities like kindness and empathy were far more important than superficial traits, enabling her to connect more deeply with others.

Be Open to Surprise: Sometimes, the best connections come from unexpected places. When Ben met Anna at a friend’s party, he initially hesitated because she wasn’t a "match" on paper. However, their undeniable chemistry blossomed into a meaningful relationship.

Practice Self-Reflection: Understanding your insecurities and what you truly want in a partner is crucial. Journaling helped Alex clarify his priorities, allowing him to move away from a checklist mentality and embrace more fulfilling connections.

Prioritize Emotional Connection: Engage in deeper conversations that go beyond surface-level attributes. When Mia focused on getting to know her dates personally, she found that shared values mattered far more than matching criteria.

While checklists can provide a sense of control in the unpredictable realm of dating, they often serve as barriers to meaningful connections. By addressing the insecurities that fuel this mentality and embracing vulnerability, we create space for deeper, more authentic relationships. Stepping away from the checklist allows us to open our hearts and discover the richness of genuine connection—where love often thrives in the unexpected.

XO Love Prescriptions

If you’re ready to transform your dating journey and build a fulfilling relationship with yourself, I’m here to help! Whether you’re interested in personalized coaching support or exploring our transformative courses, take the next step today.

Book a discovery call to discuss your unique goals and challenges, or visit our course catalog to find the perfect resources to guide you on your path to genuine connection. Don’t wait—start your journey toward authentic love and self-discovery now!